
Code Review Quadrant: Speed vs Value

#189 - The Art of Awesome Code Reviews - Michaela Greiler
Topic 3 of 10
Published Sep 2, 2024 · Clip 12:02–18:29 (6:27)
Michaela introduces her Code Review Quadrant, mapping teams on two dimensions: speed (turnaround time) and value. Fast but superficial reviews are window dressing; slow reviews with low value create the most pain. She discusses root causes like large review sizes, wrong reviewer assignment, and blindly copying policies such as mandatory two reviewers. She stresses reasoning about why you review—bug finding, knowledge sharing, mentoring—and matching reviewer selection and policies to those goals, noting research shows unfamiliar reviewers find few bugs.