Against Spec-Driven Development

Building Your Software Factory | Benedikt Stemmildt

Topic 7 of 11

Published Oct 29, 2026 · Clip 26:17–34:14 (7:57)

Benedikt criticizes spec-driven development as a return to waterfall that didn't work without AI and won't work with it, since writing better requirements upfront was never achievable. Instead he proposes a two-speed approach: supervised, collaborative prototyping for product exploration, then pushing results into an unsupervised factory that productionizes them—like an extension of the CI/CD pipeline—sometimes from buggy prototype code rather than a spec. Luca adds that detailed specs and harnesses become fragile as smarter models emerge; Benedikt shares the same problem and describes reverse-engineering new model generations by removing all skills and rules and re-adding only the guidance that proves necessary.