How Hiring Decisions Are Really Made

Confessions of a Big Tech recruiter – with Blake Stockman

Topic 3 of 7

Published Jan 8, 2025 · Clip 25:27–37:41 (12:14)

Blake explains that the larger the company, the more decentralized and layered the hiring process with committees and reviews, while companies like Uber pushed decisions close to the manager with one gut-check layer. He describes the debrief process, advocating written asynchronous feedback and candid discussion, but emphasizes the manager must own the final decision and its tradeoffs. He notes only about 20% of hires were unanimous yeses, so managers should make tradeoff discussions from imperfect signals. They discuss small companies facing larger stakes per hire and more bias, how desperation sets in after months of failed hiring, and the headcount 'use it or lose it' desperation at Uber. Blake warns that desperate hires almost always lead to regret.