
BlackBerry versus the iPhone keyboard

Tony Fadell: How to build real taste (and why AI makes it matter more)
Topic 2 of 16
Published Jun 7, 2026 · Clip 2:41–6:43 (4:02)
Prompted by the BlackBerry movie, the host asks whether the iPhone team ever doubted going keyboard-free. Tony describes the most heated, longest-running debate at Apple: one side saw BlackBerry as the market to beat, while the other noted only 1–2% of mobile users had BlackBerrys, so Apple should design for the other 98%. Drawing on his General Magic-era virtual keyboard work, the team ran months of typing-speed and error-rate tests comparing hardware keyboards against multi-touch software until the virtual keyboard was 'good enough.' With the data inconclusive on both sides, it became an opinion-based decision that Steve Jobs settled in favor of the virtual keyboard, telling dissenters to leave the room.